Florida Basic Recruit Training Program High Liability (First Aid) Practice Exam

Under what circumstance would a lawsuit against a Good Samaritan be possible?

1. If they harmed the patient intentionally

2. If they provided inadequate care

3. For any action taken during an emergency

4. They will be immune from any legal action

The correct answer is: If they provided inadequate care

A lawsuit against a Good Samaritan could be possible if they provided inadequate care. Good Samaritan laws are designed to protect individuals who voluntarily provide assistance to those who are injured or in danger from legal liability, provided that their actions are reasonable and performed in good faith. However, if the care given is grossly negligent or falls short of the standard of care expected, it could be deemed inadequate and lead to legal repercussions. This concept is important because it acknowledges that while Good Samaritans are generally protected when acting in emergency situations, there are limits to that protection. Providing inadequate care could result in further harm to the patient, which might allow for a lawsuit to be filed if the individual can demonstrate that the care was substantially deficient. Thus, the standards of care, even in emergency conditions, play a crucial role in the application of Good Samaritan protections.